You are going to make good decisions, and you are going to make bad ones.
You will not always get it right, no one has a hundred percent success rate.
But you need to make a decision.
Not making a decision, and spending more and more time arguing about the pros and cons is not helping your team, it’s confusing them.
Make a call, admit when it’s wrong, don’t flaunt it when it’s right, and move on.